13/03/2019 What is Westport? Two-year planning project to formulate - - PDF document

13 03 2019
SMART_READER_LITE
LIVE PREVIEW

13/03/2019 What is Westport? Two-year planning project to formulate - - PDF document

13/03/2019 What is Westport? Two-year planning project to formulate Fremantle a strategy to meet freight transport, trade and logistics needs for Perth and the South West for the next 50-100 years. Look to optimise existing land and


slide-1
SLIDE 1

13/03/2019 1

Westport: planning for Perth’s future freight

Nicole Lockwood

Independent Chair, Westport Taskforce

What is Westport?

  • Two-year planning project to formulate

a strategy to meet freight transport, trade and logistics’ needs for Perth and the South West for the next 50-100 years.

  • Look to optimise existing land and

infrastructure while identifying future requirements.

  • Environment and sustainability are

priorities.

  • Aim to maximise economic growth for

the State.

  • Collaborate with stakeholders and

undertake extensive community consultation.

Fremantle Kwinana/ Cockburn Sound Bunbury

The time is right… to plan

  • Perth’s population is predicted to double around

mid-century; current infrastructure will not meet long-term demand for freight.

  • Plan properly now, build when required.
  • Attract investment with a robust proposal that

provides certainty for investors – as well as industry, government and local residents.

  • Required land can be reserved.
  • Flexibility to accommodate emerging or yet-to-

be-created industries.

Westport: What we have found so far

Stage 1 progress report | Released in December 2018

Contents:

  • Background and project progress
  • Westport’s eight strategic
  • ptions
  • What problems are we trying to

solve and what opportunities are we trying to capture?

  • Stakeholder consultation and

engagement

Stage 1 work stream findings:

  • 1. Trade task
  • 2. Port capability
  • 3. Land use and utilities

infrastructure

  • 4. Preliminary environmental

and social assessment

  • 5. Supply chain

Main findings from Stage 1

Fremantle Port:

  • Could handle up to 2.1 million TEU of containers (770,000 TEU currently);
  • Capacity is limited by land (hemmed in by residential) and transport constraints (one main road in,

freight rail constrained by a single-line bridge). Kwinana Port:

  • Five bulk jetties currently but no containers. Two public jetties nearing capacity – infrastructure

upgrades are needed;

  • A greenfields container port development could possibly handle up to 6 million TEU;
  • Freight rail is close to capacity; modifications are required. Additional road freight route required;
  • Vacant land nearby suitable for an intermodal terminal;
  • Major marine and terrestrial environmental and social considerations.

Bunbury Port:

  • Has the potential to handle containers (if demand warrants), bulk, breakbulk, general cargo and

passengers;

  • Abundance of vacant port-owned and industrial land nearby;
  • Constrained by distance from Perth, road and rail links.
  • 1. Base Case

Current situation

  • 2. Optimise Fremantle Port

and transition containers to Kwinana Port over time (staged approach)

  • 3. Optimise Fremantle Port

and transition containers to Bunbury Port over time (staged approach); no containers in Kwinana

  • 4. De-industrialise

Fremantle Port and move all containers to Kwinana Port ASAP

  • 5. De-industrialise

Fremantle Port and move all containers to Bunbury Port ASAP

  • 6. Fremantle and Kwinana

Ports both have containers for the long-term

  • 7. Fremantle and Bunbury

Ports both have containers for the long-term

Westport’s eight strategic options

  • 8. Only Fremantle Port

has containers for the long- term

slide-2
SLIDE 2

13/03/2019 2

Fremantle Kwinana Bunbury

Base Case

Trade Legend Containers Bulk Passenger Vessels

Fremantle Inner Harbour Kwinana Outer Harbour Bunbury Harbour

Option 1:

The current situation

Fremantle Kwinana Fremantle Kwinana

Step 2: Build container port at Kwinana and share with Fremantle Step 3: Move all containers to Kwinana

Fremantle Fremantle Kwinana Kwinana

Base Case

Step 1: Fremantle bulk to Kwinana or Bunbury

Option 2: Optimise Fremantle and transition

containers to Kwinana over time

Bunbury Bunbury Bunbury Bunbury Fremantle Kwinana Fremantle Kwinana

Step 2: Build container port at Bunbury and share with Fremantle Step 3: Move all containers to Bunbury

Fremantle Fremantle Kwinana Kwinana

Base Case

Step 1: Fremantle bulk to Kwinana or Bunbury

Option 3: Optimise Fremantle and transition

containers to Bunbury over time

Bunbury Bunbury Bunbury Bunbury Fremantle Kwinana

Move all containers to Kwinana

Fremantle Kwinana Fremantle Kwinana

Fremantle bulk to Kwinana or Bunbury

Base Case Option 4: De-industrialise Fremantle and move all

containers to Kwinana ASAP

Bunbury Bunbury Bunbury Fremantle Kwinana

Step 2: Move all containers to Bunbury

Fremantle Kwinana Fremantle Kwinana

Step 1: Fremantle bulk to Kwinana or Bunbury

Base Case Option 5: De-industrialise Fremantle and move all

containers to Bunbury ASAP

Bunbury Bunbury Bunbury Fremantle Kwinana

Step 2: Build container port at Kwinana and share with Fremantle

Fremantle Kwinana Fremantle Kwinana

Step 1: Fremantle bulk to Kwinana or Bunbury

Base Case Option 6: Fremantle and Kwinana both have

containers for the long-term

Bunbury Bunbury Bunbury

slide-3
SLIDE 3

13/03/2019 3

Fremantle Kwinana Fremantle Kwinana Fremantle Kwinana

Step 1: Fremantle bulk to Kwinana or Bunbury

Base Case

Step 2: Build container port at Bunbury and share with Fremantle

Option 7: Fremantle and Bunbury both have

containers for the long-term

Bunbury Bunbury Bunbury Fremantle Kwinana

Base Case

Fremantle Kwinana

Option 8: Only Fremantle has

containers for the long-term

Bunbury Bunbury

Step 1: Fremantle bulk to Kwinana or Bunbury

Potential red flags OPTION 1: Base Case OPTION 2: Transition to Kwinana over time OPTION 3: Transition to Bunbury over time OPTION 4: Move all to Kwinana ASAP OPTION 5: Move all to Bunbury ASAP OPT 6: Freo & Kwinana both have containers OPT 7: Freo & Bunbury both have containers OPTION 8: Only Freo has containers Supply Chain Leach Hwy capacity Leach Hwy capacity Leach Hwy capacity South West main rail-line Leach Hwy capacity Leach Hwy capacity Leach Hwy capacity Rail capacity Rowley/ Anketell Rd upgrades South West main rail-line Rowley/ Anketell Rd upgrades Containers in Bunbury not viable Rowley/ Anketell Rd upgrades South West main rail-line Rail capacity Environmental Marine ecosystem impacts Dredging requires blasting Marine ecosystem impacts Dredging requires blasting Marine ecosystem impacts Dredging requires blasting Terrestrial impacts Truncation of Preston River Terrestrial impacts Truncation of Preston River Terrestrial impacts Truncation of Preston River Social Amenity impacts on Freo residents Impacts to fishing, horse beach, shacks Amenity impacts on Bunbury residents Impacts to fishing, horse beach, shacks Amenity impacts on Bunbury residents Impacts to fishing, horse beach, shacks Amenity impacts on Bunbury residents Amenity impacts on Freo residents Land use Limited land at Freo Limited land at Freo Land better for tourism? Land better for tourism? Commercial Freo Port capacity Two container ports unviable Bunbury financially unviable Bunbury financially unviable Two container ports unviable Bunbury financially unviable Freo Port capacity Defence Incompatible with defence Incompatible with defence Incompatible with defence

Whichever option we choose, there are issues – we know we won’t please everyone

Stage 2 work streams

1. Multi-criteria assessment (MCA) methodology 2. Environmental 3. Port operations and supply chain 4. Economic development and land activities 5. Commercial 6. Defence 7. Social licence 8. GIS

  • Cross-agency

work stream teams

  • Robust risk

management

  • Independent peer

review of all work

  • 1. Multi-criteria assessment (MCA)
  • Objective decision-making tool based
  • n data.
  • Evaluation criteria ranks options from

best to least preferred.

  • Data inputs come from Westport’s

research, past analysis and other agencies.

  • Westport will undertake several

MCAs throughout the year to determine our best option/s.

  • 2. Environmental
  • Impact on marine environment
  • Impact on terrestrial environment
  • Impact on recreational activities
  • Cumulative impact in Cockburn Sound
  • Risk assessment
  • Impact mitigation

and offsets

  • Win-win outcomes
  • Heritage
slide-4
SLIDE 4

13/03/2019 4

  • 3. Port operations and supply chain
  • Road modelling into Fremantle Port
  • Rail modelling into Fremantle Port
  • Road modelling to the Outer Harbour
  • Possible Kwinana port locations and designs
  • Bunbury-to-Perth container movement feasibility
  • Supply chain operations and corridors
  • Costs per container movement for each option
  • Locations of certain trades (i.e. cars, livestock)
  • Innovation and technology (i.e. green ports)
  • Global competitiveness
  • Sustainability and resilience
  • 4. Economic development & land activities
  • Existing and future land use activities (i.e.

industry, residential, buffer zones)

  • Future land reservations required
  • Planning – tenure, planning schemes,

zoning

  • Utility infrastructure required vs capacity
  • North Fremantle, Victoria Quay, Rous

Head development opportunities

  • Intermodal terminal strategy
  • How to utilise Latitude 32
  • Change management and transitions
  • 5. Commercial
  • Capital costs of each option
  • Operating and transition costs
  • Relative cost of financing
  • Commerciality of options
  • Governance operating model
  • Cost/benefit analysis
  • Governance and financing
  • ptions and risks
  • 6. Defence
  • Australia Marine Complex commercial, logistics and land use planning
  • Optimise innovation, expansion, global competitiveness
  • Existing and future enabling service infrastructure
  • Defence and port compatibility
  • 7. Social licence
  • Understand community concerns, interests

through engagement and consultation

  • Provide ample opportunities for feedback
  • Research community values and tolerances
  • Open and transparent communications

(Westport Beacon

  • Aboriginal Engagement Strategy

Westport Beacon rough timeline

What we have found so far feedback Kwinana rail loop Road modelling to Inner Harbour Conceptual designs of Rowley and Anketell Roads Bunbury regional supply chain Rail modelling to Inner Harbour Kwinana port location determined Concepts for new port designs Draft strategy community socialisation period Westport final proposal to Govt Garden Island Causeway investigations Aboriginal Engagement Strategy (for Stage 3) Environmental management strategies Heritage assessment UWA community values research Intermodal terminal strategy MCA

  • verview

Cockburn Sound marine modelling Kwinana environmental assessment Automotive supply chain report Social improvement strategies Commerciality

  • f options

Government and funding models Community tolerance research Economic

  • pportunities

Draft Consultation Strategy

Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov

slide-5
SLIDE 5

13/03/2019 5

Next steps

Have your say, stay up-to-date

  • Subscribe to our mailing list to

receive the Westport Beacons and project updates

  • MySayTransport consultation hub

– mysaytransport.wa.gov.au/Westport

  • Westport website

– Transport.wa.gov.au/Westport

Thank you for your support.