Meeting 1 of 3 . September 18, 2018 Agenda Welcome Introductions - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Port of San Diego Sea Level Rise Ad Hoc Committee Meeting 1 of 3

. September 18, 2018

2

2

Agenda

• Welcome – Introductions
• Rules of the Ad-Hoc
• Presentation
• Background
• Vulnerability Assessment Results
• Non-Agenda Public Comment
• Future Meeting Dates

3

3

Goals of the Sea Level Rise Ad Hoc Committee:

• 1. Review results of the Port’s sea level rise

vulnerability assessment.

• 2. Receive feedback on a sea level rise adaptation

approach.

• 3. Help to inform options for a monitoring strategy.

4

4

Agenda

• Welcome – Introductions
• Rules of the Ad-Hoc
• Presentation
• Background
• Vulnerability Assessment Results
• Non-Agenda Public Comment
• Future Meeting Dates

Background

6

6

• Water-dependent resource
• Existing flooding impacts
• Regulatory requirements

(Assembly Bill 691 State Lands)

• Coastal Commission Guidance
• Port Master Plan Update

Drivers for Sea Level Rise

7

7

AB691

• Vulnerability Assessment

– Exposure to Impacts – 2030, 2050, 2100

• Adaptation Strategies
• Financial Impacts
• Adaptive Management

– Monitoring – Triggers for Action

Submittal to State Lands Commission due June 30, 2019

PMPU

• Goals and policies to address

sea level rise

– Protect – Preserve – Adjust

• Adaptive Management

– Monitoring – Triggers for Action

Expected for Coastal Commission Certification

PMPU PEIR

• Vulnerability Assessment

– Exposure to Impacts

• Mitigation Measures
• Adaptive Management

– Monitoring – Triggers for Action

Disclose Potential Impacts through Environmental Review

AB691 and Port Master Plan Update

8

8

Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec

2020

Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec

7/19/2018

2019 2018 Board and Public Engagement

Policy Concepts PEIR Certification Draft PEIR Public Review Discussion Draft PMPU Prelim Project Description PMPU CCC Certified PMPU

CCC Program EIR PMPU AB691 Assessment

AB691 and Port Master Plan Update

Coastal Flooding Around San Diego Bay

10

10

2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018

Sept – Dec

Established a Sea Level Rise Ad Hoc Committee

11

11

← 2005 ← 2006 ← 2007 ← 2008 ← 2009 ← 2010 ← 2011 ← 2012 ← 2013 ← 2014 ← 2015 ← 2016 ← 2017 ← 2018 ← 2019 ← 2005 ← 2006 ← 2007 ← 2008 ← 2009 ← 2010 ← 2011 ← 2012 ← 2013 ← 2014 ← 2015 ← 2016 ← 2017 ← 2018 ← 2019

• Assembly Bill 32 2006
• Governor’s Executive Order S-13-08 2008
• Assembly Bill 2516 2014
• Executive Order B-30-15 2015
• Senate Bill 246 2015
• Coastal Commission Sea Level Rise Guidance 2015*
• Assembly Bill 2800 2016
• Senate Bill 32 2017
• Natural Resources Council, California

Climate Adaptation Strategy 2009, 2015, 2018

• Ocean Protection Council Sea Level Rise

Guidance 2018

*Currently being updated

Climate Change Adaption, including Sea Level Rise:

California Regulations and Guidance

12

12

• Hayward Area Shoreline Planning Agency
• San Francisco Bay Conservation and

Development Commission and NOAA

• Yolo County
• Monterey Bay Sanctuary Foundation and

Southern Monterey Bay Coastal Erosion Working Group

• State Coastal Conservancy
• Santa Cruz County
• City of Sunnyvale
• State Coastal Conservancy and

Coastal Ecosystems Institute of Northern California

• City of Redwood
• City of Hermosa Beach
• Alameda County
• Santa Clara County
• City of Goleta
• San Francisco International Airport
• Humboldt Bay Sea Level Rise Adaptation

Planning Group

• Humboldt Bay Harbor
• Marin County
• City of Foster
• City of Oxnard
• Los Angeles County
• Port of Long Beach
• City and County of San Francisco
• City of Imperial Beach
• City of Eureka
• San Francisquito Creek Joint Powers Authority
• City of Monterey
• Santa Barbara County
• CA Department of Public Health
• CA Department of

Public Health

• City of Oakland
• Association of Bay Area

Governments

• San Diego Regional Climate

Collaborative

• County of San Mateo
• Contra Costa County
• City of Carlsbad
• San Diego County

Agencies in California Addressing Sea Level Rise

12

Sea Level Rise Approach

14

14

Sea Level Rise Approach

• 1. Vulnerability

Assessment

• 2. Adaptation

Planning

• 3. Strategy

Implementation

Inform Monitor Evaluate

• 1. Vulnerability

Assessment

• 2. Adaptation

Planning

• 3. Strategy

Implementation

Trigger

Evaluate Inform Monitor

15

15

• A. Select Sea Level

Rise Projections

• B. Identify Assets
• C. Run Model and

Produce Hazard Maps

• D. Evaluate

Vulnerability and Risk

Sea Level Rise Approach

• 1. Vulnerability

Assessment

Sea Level Rise Ad-Hoc 2017

17

17

Sea Level Rise Ad-Hoc Committee

Members

• Department of Navy
• Center for Sustainable Energy
• Port Tenants Association
• San Diego State University
• University of California, San Diego
• Shelter Island Marina
• US Fish and Wildlife
• Environmental Health Coalition
• Southwest Wetlands Interpretative

Association

Advisors

Scripps Institution of Oceanography

• Dr. Julie Kalansky

United States Geological Survey

• Dr. Juliette Finzi-Hart

ICF International

• Dr. Robert Kay

Nexus Planning & Research Dennis Larson

18

18

Meeting Summary:

September 18, 2017

• Purpose, goals, and schedule
• Background on SLR Science and Coastal Modeling

October 18, 2017

• Vulnerability Assessment
• Review Assumptions
• Identify assets to be analyzed

December 7, 2017

• Progress on Vulnerability Assessment
• Receive recommendations from the Ad Hoc Committee
• Next steps

Goal: Inform the assumptions vulnerability assessment

19

19

Select Sea Level Rise Projections

Projected Sea Level Rise for San Diego Bay

Sea Level Rise Ad-Hoc 2017

20

20

Sea Level Rise Ad-Hoc 2017

• NOAA Sea Level Rise Viewer
• Coastal Storm Modeling System

(CoSMoS)

• SPAWAR

Select Sea Level Rise Model

21

21

Select Sea Level Rise Model Sea Level Rise Ad-Hoc 2017

• NOAA Sea Level Rise Viewer
• Coastal Storm Modeling System

(CoSMoS)

• SPAWAR

22

22

Select Port Assets Sea Level Rise Ad-Hoc 2017

Sea Level Rise Vulnerability Assets

Proposed Land Use Designations

• Aviation Industry
• Marine Sales & Services
• Maritime Services & Industrial
• Marine Terminal
• Visitor-Serving Marine Terminal
• Institutional/Roadways
• Commercial Fishing
• Sportfishing
• Recreational Open Space
• Conservation Inter-Tidal
• Conservation Open Space
• Recreational Berthing
• Navigation Corridor
• Anchorage
• Open Bay/Water
• Industrial & deep water Berthing
• Marine Services Berthing
• Institutional Berthing
• Commercial Fishing Berthing
• Sportfishing Berthing

Transportation

• Roads
• Rail
• Bikeway

Built Infrastructure

• Stormwater
• Sewer Lifts
• Sanitary Pump Outs
• Port Operated Docks and Piers
• Fuel Docks
• Boat Launch Ramps
• Critical Infrastructure (ie, Harbor Police, Port Operations

Buildings, Marine Terminals, etc)

Natural Resources/Environmental

• Beach Accessible Areas
• Habitats
• Contaminated uplands
• Sensitive Species Nesting Areas

23

23

Recommendations from Ad Hoc Sea Level Rise Ad-Hoc 2017

• Continue a committee or workgroup into calendar year 2018.
• Include coastal flooding and inundation beyond the District’s

jurisdictional boundaries.

• Include additional infrastructure data into the analysis.
• Partner with relevant and surrounding agencies.
• Develop schedule to reassess the projections of sea level rise as

new scientific evidence and knowledge evolves.

Vulnerability Results

Non-Agenda Public Comment

26

26

Agenda

• Welcome – Introductions
• Rules of the Ad-Hoc
• Presentation
• Background
• Vulnerability Assessment Results
• Non-Agenda Public Comment
• Future Meeting Dates

Future Meetings

28

28

28

December 6, 2018 October 16, 2018 September 18, 2018

Sea Level Rise Ad Hoc Committee

• Purpose, goals, and schedule
• Results of Vulnerability Assessment
• Background on Adaptive

Management Approach

• Options for Monitoring and Indicators

Members

• Department of Navy
• Center for Sustainable Energy
• Port Tenants Association
• University of California, San Diego
• Shelter Island Marina
• US Fish and Wildlife
• Southwest Wetlands Interpretative Association

New Members

• City of San Diego
• City of National City
• City of Chula Vista
• City of Imperial Beach
• City of Coronado
• SANDAG
• Coastal Commission

Adjourn

Thank You