VSD F2F-Pristina Social entrepreneurship in the Western Balkans - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
VSD F2F-Pristina Social entrepreneurship in the Western Balkans - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
VSD F2F-Pristina Social entrepreneurship in the Western Balkans what opportunities? 20.09.2016 Agenda Social entrepreneurship: what, why and how 11.00-12:00 Lunch Sharing thoughts and experiences from the region 13.30-15.00 Break
2
Agenda
- Social entrepreneurship: what, why and how
11.00-12:00 Lunch
- Sharing thoughts and experiences from the region
13.30-15.00 Break
- Working groups – opportunities for Western Balkans
15.30-16.45
- Key take-aways and possible way forward
16.45-17.15
3
Agenda
- Social entrepreneurship: what, why and how
- What did I hear from you?
- A definition to work with
- Sharing thoughts and experiences from the region
- Working groups – opportunities for Western Balkans
- Key take-aways and possible way forward
Why is this important and relevant? Some quotes from around the room…
4
Mixing Social & economical, building bridges
- The mix between the economic and social sphere. One cannot just put everything into
the economic aspects. One should also put the social aspects. It cannot be separate for youth, minorities.. This approach could bring new approaches and new perspectives to what we do (e.g. mixing the elderly experience with youth enthusiasm; women have a lot of potential but bigger hurdles in terms of personal circumstances)
- NGOs complain that government doesn’t listen to them, that it is not interested in
solving social issues. Perhaps social businesses could help build bridges?
Sustainability
- Supporting interventions that can survive and thrive over time
Shifting mindsets, expanding view of possibilities
- Changing people’s mindset about what is possible, what these people can do, is
also very important and powerful
- It is about ideas and possibilities
Ecosystem and system change
- All this needs be linked with changes in regulation and education
- I don’t care what they are named or do, if they don’t change the
system, it is useless
It is complicated, especially in our context… ! no entrepreneurial mindset (this is no career…), but mostly NGOs competing for grants ! lack of creativity, no inspiration, littles ideas to start with ! poor ecosystem (regulatory, tax, corruption) make it even more difficult than for small businesses ! little support for scale and replication ! no SDC program modality and difficulty to balance social and businesses objectives ! There is increasing awareness and buzz (among youth notably), and some draft laws being put together, but it is still very early stage
But then, lots of questions…and lots of caveats
5
What is this about? …it’s a company that redistributes its profits for social projects? …it’s a company that hires Romas? …we cannot have any, the legal status does not exist here… …is it a form cooperative? We have a lot of those around here…
6
Agenda
- Social entrepreneurship: what, why and how
- What did I hear from you?
- A definition to work with
- Sharing thoughts and experiences from the region
- Working groups – opportunities for Western Balkans
- Key take-aways and possible way forward
What is a Social Entrepreneur?
- An Individual with an innovative solution and a vision for solving society’s most pressing
social problems.
- Rather than leaving societal needs to the government or business sectors, they find what is
not working and solve the problem by finding an alternative approach, spreading the solution, and persuading others to take new leaps.
DISRUPTIVE SOCIAL INNOVATION ENTREPRENEURIAL QUALITIES ECONOMIC SUSTAINABILITY TO ANSWER A MAJOR SOCIAL OR ENVIRONMENTAL CHALLENGE COLLABORATIVELY
How is it different from the rest?
8
It is not about a legal form, but the existence of an adapted legislation will help
9
Countries without appropriate legal framework Countries with appropriate legal framework
NGO/Foundation status:
- Cannot reinvest profits
→ limits growth → only grant funding → no stock options
- Always legitimizing themselves
For-profit status:
- No tax exemption (also for
donations)
- Control by shareholders not
necessarily aligned
- Always legitimizing themselves
Hybrid status (combining non-profit and for-profit arms under a same roof)
- Complex to set-up and explain
- ‘Schyzophrenic’ organization
Benefit Corporation/ Flexible Purpose Corporation – USA (partly), Italy and Australia (in progress)
- includes positive impact on society, workers, the community
and the environment in addition to profit as its legally defined goals (goal, accountability, transparency)
- no tax advantage
Low-profit ltd liability company (L3C) – USA (partly)
- Stated goal of performing a socially beneficial purpose, not
maximizing income
- Hybrid structure that combines the legal and tax flexibility of
a traditional LLC, the social benefits of a nonprofit
- rganization, and the branding and market positioning
advantages of a social enterprise + it can get tax-deductible funds (not only grants) Charitable incorporated organization – UK/ ESS - France
- Facilitated LLC form for charitable organizations and social
enterprises, against ‘asset lock’ and limited dividends. Same fiscal rules as corporations. Facilitated investments Community contribution company – Canada (partly)
- Hybrid structure that allows to build up and reinvest profits
What does it take to work with Social Entreprises?
10
- 1. AVENTURES MINDSET
What does it take to work with Social Entreprises?
11
- 2. A BIGGER POOL TOWORKWITH
But 12 medals for the whole Western Balkans region!
What does it take to work with Social Entreprises?
12
- 3. PATIENCE
What does it take to work with Social Entreprises?
13
- 4. A JOURNEY COMMITMENT
Stipend
Peer-to-Peer Community
Visibility
Network Effect
Identity Collaborative Entrepreneurship Expanded Vision
Know-how & Pro-bono support
Ecosystem Change
Examples of social entrepreneurs active in VSD and job creation
14
Specialterne
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k4aZpcsJPq8
RegionalWert
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wzoIIq8w6Is
The napkin revolution
https://www.ted.com/talks/arunachalam_murug anantham_how_i_started_a_sanitary_napkin_r evolution?language=en
CoderDojo
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k5ciSFjEN1c http://www.rte.ie/news/player/2016/0618/21006826-over-700- tech-innovations-shown-at-the-coderdojo-coolest-project-awards/
Campoalto
- Skills Development
(Supply) Job Placement (Labour Market)
Job Creation (Demand)
Incluyeme
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QReTd86Hg-Q
Social enterprises that provide inclusive jobs …or help incubate self-entrepreneurs Social enterprises that facilitate access to jobs
Hiring inclusively not a trade-off or an add-on When MSD has its limits...
- It can be anyone, as long as s/he is shameless, obsessed(?),
and visionary – often a personal problem
- Putting business models ‘up-side-down’ for new opportunities
- End success will depend on venture and entrepeneur’s potential
- It can also scale and replicate quickly
and easily
- Works on hard and soft skills
- Everyone can be an entrepreneur
- Client-centric (where, when, as,
how much they can)
- Works on the DNA of the
enterprises > mindset shift
Balloon
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hgKb1R9p zqQ&feature=youtu.be
- Works on spirit and energy, as much as on skills
- Looks for entrepreneurs where there are
- Scale and replication since the start
Inclusive enterprises
Groupe VitamineT
- From ‘insertion projects’ in whatever, to a corporation with 15
companies, with 2/3 youth in insertion + personal
- accompaniment. Successes and failures
- 50m revenues, 1k employees, bought back failed enterprises
And now… lunch!
15
16
Agenda
- Social entrepreneurship: what and how
- Sharing thoughts and experiences from the region
- Presentations from current and past experiences
- Possibilities for the region
- Working groups – opportunities for Western Balkans
- Key take-aways and possible way forward
A realization: You have been speaking ‘prose’ all this time (perhaps) without knowing it
17
« Par ma foi ! il y a plus de quarante ans que je dis de la prose sans que j'en susse rien, et je vous suis le plus obligé du monde de m'avoir appris cela. ».
Act II, scene IV, Le Bourgeois Gentilhomme during an exchange with his teacher in Philosophy
18
Sharing thoughts and experiences from the region
- Serbia (Jovana)
- Bagel shops hiring victims of trafficking
- Albania (Silvana and Philipp):
- Bagel shops hiring victims of trafficking
- Roma social inclusion project
- BiH (Mersiha)
- Funky Gorilla
- Macedonia (Aneta and Biljana)
- CSO working drug addicts in agriculture
- Cooperative and market employability
- 7’ short description &
lessons learned
- 7’ Q&A
19
What could you do?
- What could you do with existing resources
and process?
- What would you like to try longer-term?
- A question, if any?
20
Possibilities for the region: some additional ideas…
Developing/ supporting new (social) enterprises in this sector in an integrated manner Partnering with (social) entreprises within larger interventions Influencing, bringing new ways of working VSD – more social entrepreneurship ‘in the doughnut’ Sectorial job creation (MSD in agriculture, hospitality, ICT…) Incubator - promoting self-entrepreneurship Convincing local companies to become ‘bCorps’ or launch PPP (and hire youth/ disadvanted) people Ecosystem – awareness and legislation
Regional approach and resources? Regional approach? Integration of new program component? Seamless and complementary with seco’s efforts? Build critical mass? Integration of new program component?
21
…and some examples of what the SDC is already doing
- r considering doing
A THEMATIC PROGRAM TO ACCELERATE SECTORIAL SOLUTIONS AN INTEGRATED PROGRAM TO DEVELOP SOC. ENT. IN LATAM
A PROGRAM TO ’IMPORT’ THE BEST IDEAS AND TRIGGER NEW INNOVATIVE VENTURES IN A COUNTRY/REGION
And now… the break!
22
23
Agenda
- Social entrepreneurship: what and how
- Sharing thoughts and experiences from the region
- Working groups – opportunities for Western Balkans
- Key take-aways and possible way forward
24
A summary…
- …
- …
- ….
25
Working groups
- Group 1 – XXX
- …
- Group 2 – XXX
- …
- Group 3 – XXX
- …
- Group 4 – XXX
- …
- .
- .
- Instructions
- List the exciting ideas – 15’
no censure please
- List the hurdles – 10’
pick your battles please
- Propose way forward to make it
happen nevertheless – 20’ be creative and entrepreneurial!
- Wrap-up and prepare to share to
plenary – 15’ This is the basis for next steps > important!
A few words of wisdom before you start
26
Social enterprises are hybrids, but no Indian goddess It is already difficult to build a profitable/impactful enterprise, be clear about the problem you want to solve:
- employ as many (young) people as possible (given unemployment
levels in the region?)
- social inclusion of disadvantaged groups
- solve market failures in specific sectors
A social enterpreneur can have many faces Do not have any prejudice, it could be the CEO of a large company, a young graduate, an NGO with a vision to go beyond the grant business Avoid the ‘small is cute’ NGO trap Most will fail, and it will take a long-time to see success. Dont bet on a few small experimental projects. Think big Be the change you want to see.. You will have to be stubborn, visionary, creative, and swim against the flow if you want to make this work and see it succeed..But then, it could also be more fun?
27
Agenda
- Social entrepreneurship: what and how
- Sharing thoughts and experiences from the region
- Working groups – opportunities for Western Balkans
- Key take-aways and possible way forward
Key take-aways and possible way forward
28
- Take aways
- …
- Way forward
- …