Wendy Holm, P.Ag. Speaking in defense of community NAIOP Commercial - - PDF document

Competing Visions of the ALR in Metro Vancouver Food, Housing or Industry?

(Tomorrow, Today or Yesterday…?)

Wendy Holm, P.Ag.

Speaking in defense of community

NAIOP Commercial Real Estate Development Association, Vancouver Chapter Development Issues Symposium

co-sponsors: SFU Centre for Dialogue (Planning Cities as if Food Matters) and Real Estate Foundation of B.C.

ALR was not [as Fraser Institute suggests, then

proceeds to argue against] created to “promote

farming and local food production” ALR was created to protect BC foodlands. ALR is working well - needs strengthening

NOTE: Italics added post presentation. The next speaker, representing the Fraser Institute, incorrectly attributes local food as the reason for creating the ALR then attempts to discredit it based on this presumption.

Flights grounded in Europe… airports close…

Londoners measure their food security in days…

The Effects of Climate Change on Agriculture, Land Resources, Water Resources and Biodiversity in the United States

U.S. Climate Change Science Program Synthesis and Assessment Product 4.3 May 2008

Already effecting… Increasing temperatures Variable rainfall Increasing crop failures

US military warns oil output may dip causing massive shortages by 2015

• Shortfall could reach 10m barrels a day, report says
• Cost of crude oil is predicted to top $100 a barrel

Terry Macalister guardian.co.uk, Sunday 11 April 2010 18.47 BST

The Environmental Food Crisis

UN Environment Programme

25% loss in food production due to climate change, water scarcity, invasive pests, land degradation

Canadians continue to enjoy the second lowest food costs (9.9% of total consumer expenditures) of all OECD member nations.

TODAY, Canadians enjoy amongst the lowest food costs in world

food security

food safety peak oil climate change

peak food

PRESSURE ON FARMLAND

√ FARMLAND SPECULATION √ LACK POLICY SUPPORT FOR AGRICULTURE

JAWS OF THE CROCODILE…

THE COASTAL CROCODILE…

BC Agricultural Land Reserve

4.8 mil ha 11.8 mil ac SC: 4%of ALR Metro: 60,892 ac Fraser V: 71,824 ac Highest capability land in Canada food footprint= .56 ha/person

10,214 acres lost 7,267 acres added

11,391 AC PRIME FARMLAND LOST - PROPOSED SITE C DAM

Class 1: 474 acres Class 2: 7,367 acres Class 3: 2,056 acres 9,897 acres Class 4: 437 acres Class 5: 1,057 acres 1,494 acres

ALR was not created [as Fraser Institute suggests,

then proceeds to argue against] to “promote

farming and local food production” ALR was created to protect BC foodlands. ALR is working well - needs strengthening

NOTE: Italics added post presentation. The next speaker, representing the Fraser Institute, incorrectly attributes local food as the reason for creating the ALR then attempts to discredit it based on this presumption.

How can we make the ALR work better? – Stop private applications for ALR removal – Improve awareness of good planning tools

e.g. Local Government Policy Options to Protect Agricultural Land and Improve the Viability of Farming in Metro Vancouver. April 6, 2010

– Create leasing opportunities on fallow land – Policies to Amalgamate parcel size – Support infrastructure, especially cooperative – Support urban, peri-urban, rural food production

How can we make the ALR work better? – Support market linkages and urban markets – Build houses on uplands not farmlands

“Agricultural Urbanism” NOT model for ALR

(Gilmore Estates, Terra Nova, Garden City Lands, Southlands…)

– Reduce speculation of foodlands by developers – Un-muzzle professionals to speak for public interest – Government support + commitment to food “Food security is as important to this country’s future well-being – and the world’s - as energy security. We need to produce more food. We need to do it

• sustainably. And we need to make sure that what

we eat safeguards our health…” UK Environment Secretary Hilary Benn Food 2030 Strategy, Oxford Farming Conference January 6, 2010

RESPECT

Wendy Holm, P.Ag. THE HOLM TEAM

theholmteam.ca

wendy@theholmteam.ca

604.947.2893

NOTE:

• Two slides in the above were changed

post-presentation: slide 2 to clarify and slide 18 to correct and expand.

• Yes, I must admit, slide 28 is local food in

a market in northern Italy. Will look for an equally gorgeous display at one of our local farmers’ markets for future use…