SLIDE 1 NABIE Conference 2014 1
STEEP AND LOW SLOPE ROOF SYSTEMS HISTORIC AND EXISTING FACILITIES INSTITUTIONAL, COMMERCIAL AND INDUSTRIAL FACILITIES NEW CONSTRUCTION DESIGN, PEER REVIEWS, CONSTRUCTION ADMIN / PROJECT MGT EXTERIOR WALLS AND WATERPROOFING ASSESSMENTS HIGH-RISE RESIDENTIAL
Who We Are
Independent, third-party roofing and waterproofing consultant Serving educational, institutional, governmental and private sector clients throughout the US, Canada and Mexico. Established in 1999
NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE
SLIDE 2 NABIE Conference 2014 2
What We Do
Perform roof condition assessments Develop roof O&M plans Develop repair or replacement scope of work and preliminary opinions of cost Prepare bidding and construction documents Assist with bidding Perform construction phase project management and construction administration services through project closeout
NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE
What We Do
Perform periodic, daily, part-time or full-time construction observation for conformance with Contract Documents Perform forensic roof leak investigations Perform non-destructive roof moisture surveys Perform roof hail/wind damage assessments Provide roof litigation technical assistance
NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE
SLIDE 3 NABIE Conference 2014 3
Why We Are Here
To provide you with some insight on how we perform roof inspections, in general, at the four standard levels described in the NABIE Standard of Practice.
NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE
NABIE Standard of Practice
Adopted December 12, 2011 Effective March 1, 2012
NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE
SLIDE 4 NABIE Conference 2014 4
Levels A-D
LEVEL A – VISUAL INSPECTION LEVEL B – FUNCTIONAL INSPECTION LEVEL C – SPECIALIZED INSPECTION LEVEL D – REMEDIAL DESIGN AND REPAIR
NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE
LEVEL A - VISUAL INSPECTION
Visual inspection of specified systems and components in a representative manner from locations accessible to
- rdinary users; results and conclusions
presented in verbal or written summary.
NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE
SLIDE 5 NABIE Conference 2014 5
LEVEL B – FUNCTIONAL INSPECTION
Level A plus more detailed observation, documentation by written report, may require accessing areas normally not accessible to ordinary
- users. Results and conclusions presented in written
report bearing the official seal of the Building Inspection Engineer (BIE). Deficiencies are listed and subjective opinions regarding serviceability or need for repair provided in report. Major items restricted from inspection or outside the expertise of the BIE shall be listed. Report may contain limitations and recommendations for further evaluation as deemed necessary by the BIE.
NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE
LEVEL C - SPECIALIZED INSPECTION Level B plus more comprehensive evaluation of specified systems or components, using specialized equipment, historical research, functional testing, analysis or other tasks deemed necessary by the Building Inspection Engineer. May require invasive techniques, material removal or destructive testing.
NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE
SLIDE 6 NABIE Conference 2014 6
LEVEL D - REMEDIAL DESIGN AND REPAIR
Level C plus design or detailed consideration of repair options or improvements generally beyond the scope of Building Inspection. Written reports may include working drawings
- r detailed specifications.
NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE
LEVEL A – VISUAL INSPECTION
Questions to ask, information to gather before getting on the roof:
Who is most familiar with the roofs? (Usually
the person with all the keys).
Are there any active leaks? Has there been a history of leaks? Do you have copies of roof repair invoices? Can we review your maintenance logs/work
- rder logs for current/past roof maintenance
history?
NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE
SLIDE 7 NABIE Conference 2014 7
LEVEL A – VISUAL INSPECTION
Determine Roof Type/Classification:
Low-Sloped Roof Systems
Asphalt or Coal Tar Pitch BUR Smooth surfaced, gravel surfacing, pavers Modified Bitumen Smooth surfaced, granule surfaced Single-Ply TPO, PVC, EPDM Sprayed Polyurethane Foam IRMA Garden Roof Metal
NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE
LEVEL A – VISUAL INSPECTION
Determine Roof Type/Classification
Steep-Sloped Roof Systems
Metal Architectural or Structural Solid Deck or Purlins Insulation above the deck or draped over purlins Insulation on ceiling or within cathedral ceiling plenum Single-locked, double-locked or snap-locked Surface fastened Galvanized, Galvalume, Pre-Finished Galvanized Copper Aluminum, Pre-Finished Aluminum
NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE
SLIDE 8 NABIE Conference 2014 8
LEVEL A – VISUAL INSPECTION
Determine Roof Type/Classification
Steep-Sloped Roof Systems
Shingles Asphalt Composition 3-Tab Metal Slate Wood shakes and shingles Tile Clay Concrete
NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE
LEVEL A – VISUAL INSPECTION
What we look for:
Drainage efficiency – is the water getting off the
roof?
Ponding?
NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE
SLIDE 9
NABIE Conference 2014 9
SLIDE 10
NABIE Conference 2014 10
SLIDE 11 NABIE Conference 2014 11
LEVEL A – VISUAL INSPECTION
What we look for:
Number and type of rooftop A/C units
Package units Down discharge Side discharge Curb supported Structural stand NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE
SLIDE 12
NABIE Conference 2014 12
SLIDE 13
NABIE Conference 2014 13
SLIDE 14 NABIE Conference 2014 14
LEVEL A – VISUAL INSPECTION
What we look for:
Split systems Support type Wood sleepers Non-wood sleepers Concrete pad PPH NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE
SLIDE 15 NABIE Conference 2014 15
NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE
SLIDE 16 NABIE Conference 2014 16
NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE
SLIDE 17 NABIE Conference 2014 17
NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE
LEVEL A – VISUAL INSPECTION
What we look for:
Split systems Utility Connections Roof Penetrations NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE
SLIDE 18 NABIE Conference 2014 18
NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE
SLIDE 19 NABIE Conference 2014 19
NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE
SLIDE 20 NABIE Conference 2014 20
NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE
LEVEL A – VISUAL INSPECTION
What we look for:
Roof material age/condition Looks can be deceiving or not
NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE
SLIDE 21 NABIE Conference 2014 21
NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE
SLIDE 22 NABIE Conference 2014 22
NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE
SLIDE 23 NABIE Conference 2014 23
NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE
SLIDE 24
NABIE Conference 2014 24
SLIDE 25
NABIE Conference 2014 25
SLIDE 26
NABIE Conference 2014 26
SLIDE 27
NABIE Conference 2014 27
SLIDE 28
NABIE Conference 2014 28
SLIDE 29 NABIE Conference 2014 29
LEVEL B – FUNCTIONAL INSPECTION
Before getting on the roof:
Review aerial photographs Exterior elevations - signs of water stains,
streaks on exterior walls
Exterior elevations – roof drainage features Locations of active/previous leaks Underside of deck – indications of rust,
deterioration, roof leaks
NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE
SLIDE 30
NABIE Conference 2014 30
SLIDE 31
NABIE Conference 2014 31
SLIDE 32
NABIE Conference 2014 32
SLIDE 33
NABIE Conference 2014 33
SLIDE 34 NABIE Conference 2014 34
LEVEL B – FUNCTIONAL INSPECTION
Where does/should the water go?
Off the edge – check embedded edge metal lap
joints
Gutters and downspouts – drain efficiently,
ponding
Roof drains – strainers missing, mismatched
strainers, strainers full of debris
Edge scuppers – notorious for ponding,
inefficient drainage
NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE
SLIDE 35 NABIE Conference 2014 35
LEVEL B – FUNCTIONAL INSPECTION
Through-wall scuppers – debris reduces
efficiency
Secondary emergency overflow provisions Ponding
NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE
SLIDE 36
NABIE Conference 2014 36
SLIDE 37
NABIE Conference 2014 37
SLIDE 38
NABIE Conference 2014 38
SLIDE 39
NABIE Conference 2014 39
SLIDE 40
NABIE Conference 2014 40
SLIDE 41 NABIE Conference 2014 41
LEVEL B – FUNCTIONAL INSPECTION
The devil is in the details
Roofing material laps/joints Terminations, area dividers, expansion joints Horizontal to vertical transitions (base
flashings)
Rooftop equipment Rooftop piping Adjacent wall/parapet wall watertightness
NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE
SLIDE 42
NABIE Conference 2014 42
SLIDE 43
NABIE Conference 2014 43
SLIDE 44
NABIE Conference 2014 44
SLIDE 45
NABIE Conference 2014 45
SLIDE 46
NABIE Conference 2014 46
SLIDE 47
NABIE Conference 2014 47
SLIDE 48 NABIE Conference 2014 48
LEVEL B – FUNCTIONAL INSPECTION
Roof hatch safety rails Skylight fall protection guards Others?
NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE
SLIDE 49
NABIE Conference 2014 49
SLIDE 50 NABIE Conference 2014 50
LEVEL C – SPECIALIZED INSPECTION
Destructive testing:
Core cuts (minimum of 1 per roof area, plus 1
additional sample per 10,000 square feet of roof area)
Number of plies in multi-ply system Width of overlap at membrane laps Thickness and type of coverboard Thickness and type of insulation
More than one roof?
NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE
LEVEL C – SPECIALIZED INSPECTION
Deck type Verification of non-destructive roof moisture
testing, wet is wet, dry is dry
NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE
SLIDE 51
NABIE Conference 2014 51
SLIDE 52
NABIE Conference 2014 52
SLIDE 53
NABIE Conference 2014 53
SLIDE 54
NABIE Conference 2014 54
SLIDE 55 NABIE Conference 2014 55
LEVEL C – SPECIALIZED INSPECTION
Non-destructive roof moisture surveys
Infrared camera Electrical impedance meters Nuclear gauges Electronic leak detection
NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE
SLIDE 56
NABIE Conference 2014 56
SLIDE 57 NABIE Conference 2014 57
LEVEL C – SPECIALIZED INSPECTION
Functional Testing
Fastener pull-out resistance (Com-Ten) Exposed fastener vacuum tester (Wallace
Sales Company)
Roof surface elevation survey
NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE
SLIDE 58 NABIE Conference 2014 58
LEVEL C – SPECIALIZED INSPECTION
Code Compliance
Energy conservation code – meets current
code for R-value, reflectivity?
Plumbing code – roof drains and scupper
- penings sized to meet current code?
Plumbing code - secondary emergency
- verflow drainage provided, required?
NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE
SLIDE 59 NABIE Conference 2014 59
LEVEL D – REMEDIAL DESIGN AND REPAIR Documentation
Roof overall dimensions, slope Roof drains - number, location and diameter Through-wall scuppers - number, location and
dimensions
Gutter dimensions Gutter downspouts - number, location and
dimensions
Parapet wall dimensions - height and width, all
elevations
NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE
LEVEL D – REMEDIAL DESIGN AND REPAIR
Rooftop equipment - number, type, location and
condition
Rooftop equipment - curb size, base flashing
height
Rooftop equipment – number, type and location
- f abandoned, non-functional equipment
Rooftop piping: location, elevation above
finished roof, support type and spacing
NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE
SLIDE 60 NABIE Conference 2014 60
LEVEL D – REMEDIAL DESIGN AND REPAIR
Determine if Licensed Structural Engineer
required to assess existing roof framing structure or deck
Determine if Licensed MEP Engineer required
to assess rooftop MEP equipment.
NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE
SLIDE 61 NABIE Conference 2014 61
NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE
SLIDE 62 NABIE Conference 2014 62
NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE
SLIDE 63 NABIE Conference 2014 63
NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE
SLIDE 64 NABIE Conference 2014 64
NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE
LEVEL D – REMEDIAL DESIGN AND REPAIR Destructive testing:
Core cuts Edge conditions - wood blocking type and
thickness, deck termination assembly/condition
Wall substrate at parapet walls/rise walls Masonry wall weeps covered over during
reroofing?
Wall and edge conditions below clerestory
windows
NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE
SLIDE 65 NABIE Conference 2014 65
NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE
SLIDE 66 NABIE Conference 2014 66
NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE
SLIDE 67 NABIE Conference 2014 67
NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE
SLIDE 68 NABIE Conference 2014 68
LEVEL D – REMEDIAL DESIGN AND REPAIR
Location and type of through-wall flashing, true
through-wall or saw-cut reglet?
True roof expansion joint or roof area divider? Roof expansion joint continuous or
discontinuous at parapet walls?
NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE
SLIDE 69 NABIE Conference 2014 69
NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE
SLIDE 70 NABIE Conference 2014 70
NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE
SLIDE 71 NABIE Conference 2014 71
LEVEL D – REMEDIAL DESIGN AND REPAIR Functional Testing
Fastener pull-out resistance (Com-Ten) Exposed fastener vacuum tester (Wallace
Sales Company)
Roof surface elevation survey Coating adhesion testing
NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE
LEVEL D – REMEDIAL DESIGN AND REPAIR Drawings, Specifications, Bidding Documents
Jim Whitten Roof Consultants, LLC + Tejas
Design, PLLC joint venture.
NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE
SLIDE 72 NABIE Conference 2014 72
NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE
SLIDE 73 NABIE Conference 2014 73
NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE
SLIDE 74 NABIE Conference 2014 74
NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE
SLIDE 75 NABIE Conference 2014 75
NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE
SLIDE 76 NABIE Conference 2014 76
NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE NABIE 2014 ANNUAL BULDING INSPECTION ENGINEERING CONFERENCE