Work Package 1 Management and Practical Aspects Task 1.1: - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
Work Package 1 Management and Practical Aspects Task 1.1: Executive Management (UAB with support of all WP leaders) (M1-48). Task 1.2: Financial Management (UAB with support of all WP leaders) (M1-48). Task 1.3: Scientific Coordination Support
Task 1.1: Executive Management (UAB with support of all WP leaders) (M1-48). Task 1.2: Financial Management (UAB with support of all WP leaders) (M1-48). Task 1.3: Scientific Coordination Support (UAB with support of all WP leaders) (M1-48). Task 1.4: Coordination/Synergies with Relevant EU Projects and Other Initiatives (UAB with support of all WP leaders) (M1-48).
This WP is dedicated to the management and coordination of the activities of the project, including overall legal, scientific, financial and administrative issues. This includes:
Assembly;
Carefully plan your travel budget Other direct costs
Reporting Periods
Coordination will sollicit information for technical and financial reporting More info available at: H2020 Online Manual & AMGA
http://ec.europa.eu/research/participants/data/ref/h2020/grants_manual/amga/h2020-amga_en.pdf
Reporting Period Starting Month Ending Month Duration (M) 1 1 12 12 2 13 30 18 3 31 48 18
Yearly Progress Meetings Any candidates to host the first progress meeting?
Progress meeting Month Date Observation First 12 May 2017 Advisory Board Meeting Second 24 May 2018 Third 36 May 2019 Advisory Board Meeting Final 46 March 2020
More information on Management Structure: Magic Consortium Agreement Magic Grant Agreement (Annex1 DoA Part B) http://felipsoriano.com/magic-nexus/documents/ (http://magic-nexus.eu/documents)
Task Force/Work Package
Communication and visibility
GIS
Science for Policy
Energy
Water
Agriculture/food
Data management: Ansel Renner; Communication and Visibility, Dissemination: Samuele Lo Piano; Synergies Plans: Violeta Cabello; GIS: Tarik Serrano; Gender Issues: Maddalena Ripa; Thematic: Science for Policy: Zora Kova; Water: Violeta Cabello; Energy: Mario Giampietro; Agriculture and food: Tarik Serrano.
Data management/WP3: ansel.renner@gmail.com Communication and Visibility: samuele.lopiano@uab.cat, vcabellov@gmail.com, maddalena.ripa@gmail.com GIS: tarik.serrano@uab.cat; Thematic: Science for Policy: zora.kovacic@uab.cat, vcabellov@gmail.com Water: vcabellov@gmail.com , zora.kovacic@uab.cat Energy: mario.giampietro@uab.cat, samuele.lopiano@uab.cat, tarik.serrano@gmail.com, maddalena.ripa@gmail.com; Agriculture and food: tarik.serrano@gmail.com, maddalena.ripa@gmail.com Please do not forget always in cc: samuele.lopiano@uab.cat
Meetings: samuele.lopiano@uab.cat, sandra.bukkens@uab.cat Advisory Board, General Assembly: mario.giampietro@uab.cat, samuele.lopiano@uab.cat, sandra.bukkens@uab.cat Synergy Plan (with SIM4NEXUS & other projects): samuele.lopiano@uab.cat, vcabellov@gmail.com, sandra.bukkens@uab.cat Technical and financial reports/issues (deliverables): samuele.lopiano@uab.cat, sandra.bukkens@uab.cat Minutes (milestones): samuele.lopiano@uab.cat, sandra.bukkens@uab.cat
Roberta.Siciliano@unina.it Michele.Staiano@unina.it
ICTA 15 june 2016
MAGIC LOGO (we have to vote for)
Nexus Information Space (NIS) capable of guaranteeing the coherence
non-equivalent quantitative representations of feasibility, viability and desirability of socio-ecological systems in relation to the nexus across different scales and different dimensions.
✧ SYSTEM: is the supporting technology that provides the data on
flow and fund, implements grammars (the expected relationships between components of the system in a particular context).
✧ SPACE: handles the technical information system, the databases,
the GIS, the visualization, the info-graphics, and the video aspects
.
carry-out a quality check on the integrated representation across scales associated with the chosen Quantitative Story Telling.
types of quantitative analysis (individuating relevant data and combining chosen models) on the basis of the grammars developed in WP4.
UAB with support of all partners, specifically the task 4.2: Making grammars.
Which expertizes we can rely upon?
Twente water footprint water accounting grammar Bergen post-normal science data for governance C.A. carbon footprint climate change water availability UniNA statistics ML & visualization UAB assembling nexus MuSIASEM ITC data engineering water/energy JRC Sensitivity and QST participatory processes Wageningen food production crops & livestock Hutton land use geography & GIS
Work package number
3
Start Date or Starting Event M1 - M48 Work package title Nexus Information Space Participant number 7 9 1 2 3 4 8 Short name of UNINA ITC UAB JHI WUR UT UiB Person/months per participant:
48 32 18 4 14 24 2
@UniNA www.stad.unina.it/2016 STAD is “city” in Dutch. [Statistics, technology, analysis of data] is a “research city” of University
aggregate from almost anywhere. This city contains a lot of "buildings" to create and work out ideas, provide statistical science, transfer technology, analyze data with a meta- disciplinary approach, "crossing the bridge" towards other scientific communities.
Massimo Aria
Anto nio D’Ambro sio Roberta Siciliano Michele Staiano
@UniNA expertise being leader WP3
Multidimensional Data Analysis, Visualization
Management perspective
Task 3.1: Data Management Plan (UNINA with support of ITC and UAB) [M1-M6]
Define a Data Management Plan on the structured metadata repository maintained by the consortium, the various methods of formalization used in the different case studies proposed in WP4, WP5, WP6, and the management of the data generated during the project, in accordance with the “Guidelines on Data Management in Horizon 2020”.
Task 3.2: Identifying Data and Populating and Structuring Databases (UNINA with support of ITC, UT, UAB, HUTTON, WU, UiB) [M1-M48]
Identification of statistical, scientific and other databases at local, regional, national and EU levels required for the chosen implementation of the NIS in the various case studies and creation of a scheme for the deployment of a structured metadata repository to be maintained by all partners in order to safely share the data sources required to formalize the various grammars selected for the specific assessments.
Task 3.3 Supporting the Activities of WP4, 5 and 6 (UNINA with support
Assisting the activities of WP4, WP5 and WP6 in the definition and integration of different metrics, the integration of different analytical frameworks, the design and integration of databases and visualization tools according to the chosen QST. The experience accumulated during the project will be used to define a tool-kit making it possible a quantitative characterization of different applications of the nexus framework developed in WP4.
Task 3.4 Visualization (UNINA with support of ITC, UAB, HUTTON, WU, UT, UiB) [M12-M48]
Development and testing of a system of integrated visualization of the quantitative results about the feasibility, viability and desirability in the selected case studies to be used for presenting the results of the project in the Nexus Dialogue Space (WP2), and to be included in the Nexus Knowledge Hub (WP7).
UniNA
ITC
Statistics
Plan Do Check Act survey design data collection data validation imputation data selection data transformation data organization pre-processing method selection data processing statistical analysis dissemination I when data are not available and need to be collected II when data are accessible and need to be selected III when datasets are available and need to be processed
Nexus Information Space
Data sources Models Supporting technologies
Nexus Information System
Compiler
D3.1 Data Management Plan on the structured metadata repository maintained by the consortium, the various methods of formalization used in the different case studies proposed in WP4, WP5, WP6, and the management of the data generated during the project (M6) D3.2 Report on visualization methods developed in the NIS (M42) D3.3 Report on the datasets and tools used to support the applications of Quantitative Story Telling (M48) MS15 Data Repository Responsible: 7 – UNINA month 12
Basic data repository to support the applications of WP4,5, and 6 for use by all consortium members. To be in place by month 12, and then gradually expanded during the course of the project
hiring two junior researcher (one dedicated to data sources and one to models and their surrogates)
and schemata for integration of sources (e.g. CIM★)
past experience and sub-contracting the last year.
Develop adapters with the tight collaboration of ITC: we already started to cooperate (active exchanges).
Z O R A K O V A C I C , T A R I K S E R R A N O
WORK PACKAGE 4
WP3
NEXUS US Information
NEXUS US Dialog
ue Space
WP4
Defin finin ing the Quantitati ntitative ve Story ry-Tell Tellin ing
WP2
EU admini nist strat ration
WP1
interac eractions tions during ng the proje ject ct permanent manent platfo tform rm of
interac eraction tion
WP WP7
NEXUS Knowledg edge Hub Hub Quality check on
assessm essment of innovati ations
WP6
Quality check on
robustness ess of narrative ves
WP5
CASE STUDIES DIES
QUANTITATIVE STORY-TELLING FOR GOVERNANCE
OVERSIMPLIFICATION
“Based on historical trends, our projections show that population numbers should keep increasing: we look to the upcoming Thanksgiving with confidence…”
GDP WILL RESUME GROWTH IN 2009
European Commission, Economic Forecast, autumn 2007. Directorate-General for Economic and Financial Affairs, European Economy, No. 7/2007
GDP WILL RESUME GROWTH IN 2010
European Commission, Economic Forecast, autumn 2008. Directorate-General for Economic and Financial Affairs, European Economy, No. 6/2008
GDP WILL RESUME GROWTH IN 2011
European Commission, Economic Forecast, autumn 2009. Directorate-General for Economic and Financial Affairs, European Economy, No. 10/2009
GDP WILL RESUME GROWTH IN 2012
European Commission, Economic Forecast, autumn 2010. Directorate-General for Economic and Financial Affairs, European Economy, No. 7/2010
GDP WILL RESUME GROWTH IN 2013
European Commission, Economic Forecast, autumn 2011. Directorate-General for Economic and Financial Affairs, European Economy, No. 6/2011
GDP WILL RESUME GROWTH IN 2014
European Commission, Economic Forecast, autumn 2013. Directorate-General for Economic and Financial Affairs, European Economy, No. 7/2013
EU (28 countries) Eurostat EC Forecast, abs average error 2.4 pts (140%) 2009
2.4 error=7.2 2010 1.7 1 error=0.7 2011 1.4 1.5 error=0.1 2012
2 error=2.7 2013
1.5 error=1.6 Euro Area (18 countries) Eurostat EC Forecast, abs. average error 2.5 pts (170%) 2009
2.1 error=6.9 2010 1.7 1 error=0.7 2011 1.3 1.5 error=0.2 2012
2 error=1.1 2013
1.4 error=2.0
Eurostat http://epp.eurostat.ec.europa.eu/tgm/table.do?tab=table&plugin=1&language=en&pcode=t sdec100
FORECASTS HAVE A MEAN REVERTING CORE
COMPLEXITY
Multi-scale analysis
Event: THE DEATH OF A PARTICULAR INDIVIDUAL EXPLANATION 1 --> “no oxygen supply in the brain”
Space-time scale: VERY SMALL Example: EMERGENCY ROOM Implications for action: APPLY KNOWN PROCEDURES Based on known HOW - past affecting strongly present actions
EXPLANATION 2 --> “affected by lung cancer”
Space-time scale: SMALL Example: MEDICAL TREATMENT Implications for action: KNOWN PROCEDURES & EXPERIMENTATION Looking for a better HOW - past affecting present, but room for change
EXPLANATION 3 --> “individual was a heavy smoker”
Space-time scale: MEDIUM Example: MEETING AT HEALTH MINISTRY Implications for action: MIX EXPERIENCE AND WANTS INTO POLICY Considering HOW and WHY - past and “virtual future” affecting present
EXPLANATION 4 --> “humans must die”
Space-time scale: VERY LARGE Example: SUSTAINABILITY ISSUES Implications for action: DEALING WITH THE TRAGEDY OF CHANGE Considering WHY - “virtual future” (values) affecting present
pre-analytical definition
car airplane boat truck bike horse WHAT tank
Economic
Criterion Safety Criterion Cultural Criterion Driving quality Criterion
SEMANTIC FRAMING OF THE ANALYSIS
WHY
moving people
moving people
moving people short distance moving people long distance moving around when at war moving heavy loads GOALS + CONTEXT
Economic
Criterion Safety Criterion Cultural Criterion Driving quality Criterion
Can we use the same multi-criteria space to characterize the choice between a TRABANT and a FERRARI?
NO WAY!
It does not provide enough information to either those interested in buying a TRABANT, nor those interested in buying a FERRARI
The two types of buyer will requires a different selection of indicators and attributes: a different WHAT
(18 October 1919 – 28 March 2013)
George Box
Box, G. E. P., and Draper, N. R., (1987), Empirical Model Building and Response Surfaces, John Wiley & Sons, New York, NY. P 424
“Essentially, all models are wrong, but some are useful.”
decoding
Non-equivalent Perceptions
encoding
Non-equivalent Representations
ecologist economist biologist engineer sociologist “SYSTEM”
Plurality of Observations
relevant attributes
models
PLURALISM
19
ROSEN’S MODELLING RELATION
Narrative
NEW NARRATIVES
What makes a model useful? Who defines the purpose? GDP was created during WWII in order to measure productive capacity to face the war – is this model still useful to assess economic performance?
QUANTITATIVE CHECK OF THE USEFULNESS OF NARRATIVES
TET TET GDP GDP $ MJ El Salvador = 12.6 MJ/$ Finland = 12.6 MJ/$ = TET TET THA THA GDP GDP THA THA Year 1997
MJ MJ US$ US$ = 12.6 !!! 12.6 !!! No significance ! No external referent ! Finland = 29.73 MJ/hr El Salvador = 2.92 MJ/hr Finland = 2.35 $/hr El Salvador = 0.23 $/hr (20,600 $/year p.c) (2,020 $/year p.c)
ELPPW level n-1 ELPAG ELPPS ELPSG 14 $/hour 27 $/hour 31 $/hour 2 $/hour 0.8 $/hour 5 $/hour
HAAG HASG HAPS
DEALING WITH UNCERTAINTY
Technical know-how ≠ Large scale application
system
flows/ha
WHAT TYPE OF QUANTIFICATION?
DAY 2 – WP4
HOW WP4 WORKS
1. Training 2. Development of analytical tools 3. Analysis of 8-10 EU countries 4. Global drivers 5. Planetary boundaries 6. Externalization 7. Interaction with EC 8. Updating Grammars
Case studies WP5 Case studies WP6
WP4 TASKS
1. Training (UAB with support of all other partners) MuSIASEM Internal Project Training Session
Alternatively Liphe4 Summer School in 11-15 July !!!
WP4 TASKS
(UAB with support of HUTTON, WU, UT, UiB, UNINA, CA, ITC) Definition of a general framework for the quantitative analysis of the nexus based on “grammars”
WP4 TASKS
(WU with support of UAB, HUTTON, UT, UiB, UNINA, CA, ITC) Develop a protocol for the characterization the whole EU with a granularity of NUTS1 or NUTS 2 regions
8-10 EU countries NUTS 1 NUTS 2
WP4 TASKS
Deliverable 4.3 4.3 Global Drivers 4.4 Planetary Boundaries 4.5 Externalization
Deliverable led by University of Twente
WP4 TASKS
(UAB with support of WU, HUTTON, UT, UNINA, CA, ITC) Generate simulations of the effect of existing drivers
water and energy requirements
WP4 TASKS
(WU with support of UAB, HUTTON, UT, UNINA, CA, ITC) DPSIR of different types of SES in the world to check the limits to the expansion of societal consumption determined by external constraints
WP4 TASKS
(UT with support of UAB, HUTTON, WU, UNINA, CA, ITC) Effects of EU externalization of impacts to other SES because of imports
imported energy
WP4 TASKS
(UAB and JRC with support of all other partners) Interactive Meeting with EU Staff (from Policy and Innovation Teams) This meeting will lead to the selection of case studies
WP4 TASKS
(UAB with all other partners) Revisions and updating of the developed analytical frameworks in task 4.2 in response to the feed-backs received from the case studies in WP5 and WP6.
WP4 PERSONS/MONTHS
Partner number WP4 effort 1- UAB 48 2- HUTTON 4 3 – WU 24 4 – UT 24 5 – UiB 2 6 – JRC 4 7 – UNINA 10 8 – CA 18 9 – ITC 3 total 137
Z O R A K O V A C I C , T A R I K S E R R A N O
WORK PACKAGE 4
WP3
NEXUS US Information
NEXUS US Dialog
ue Space
WP4
Defin finin ing the Quantitati ntitative ve Story ry-Tell Tellin ing
WP2
EU admini nist strat ration
WP1
interac eractions tions during ng the proje ject ct permanent manent platfo tform rm of
interac eraction tion
WP WP7
NEXUS Knowledg edge Hub Hub Quality check on
assessm essment of innovati ations
WP6
Quality check on
robustness ess of narrative ves
WP5
CASE STUDIES DIES
HOW WP4 WORKS
1. Training 2. Development of analytical tools 3. Analysis of 8-10 EU countries 4. Global drivers 5. Planetary boundaries 6. Externalization 7. Interaction with EC 8. Updating Grammars
Case studies WP5 Case studies WP6
WP4 TASKS
1. Training (UAB with support of all other partners) MuSIASEM Internal Project Training Session
Alternatively Liphe4 Summer School in 11-15 July !!!
WP4 TASKS
(UAB with support of HUTTON, WU, UT, UiB, UNINA, CA, ITC) Definition of a general framework for the quantitative analysis of the nexus based on “grammars”
WP4 TASKS
(WU with support of UAB, HUTTON, UT, UiB, UNINA, CA, ITC) Develop a protocol for the characterization the whole EU with a granularity of NUTS1 or NUTS 2 regions
8-10 EU countries NUTS 1 NUTS 2
WP4 TASKS
Deliverable 4.3 4.3 Global Drivers 4.4 Planetary Boundaries 4.5 Externalization
Deliverable led by University of Twente
WP4 TASKS
(UAB with support of WU, HUTTON, UT, UNINA, CA, ITC) Generate simulations of the effect of existing drivers
water and energy requirements
WP4 TASKS
(WU with support of UAB, HUTTON, UT, UNINA, CA, ITC) DPSIR of different types of SES in the world to check the limits to the expansion of societal consumption determined by external constraints
WP4 TASKS
(UT with support of UAB, HUTTON, WU, UNINA, CA, ITC) Effects of EU externalization of impacts to other SES because of imports
imported energy
WP4 TASKS
(UAB and JRC with support of all other partners) Interactive Meeting with EU Staff (from Policy and Innovation Teams) This meeting will lead to the selection of case studies
WP4 TASKS
(UAB with all other partners) Revisions and updating of the developed analytical frameworks in task 4.2 in response to the feed-backs received from the case studies in WP5 and WP6.
WP4 PERSONS/MONTHS
Partner number WP4 effort 1- UAB 48 2- HUTTON 4 3 – WU 24 4 – UT 24 5 – UiB 2 6 – JRC 4 7 – UNINA 10 8 – CA 18 9 – ITC 3 total 137
Workpages 5 & 6 (James Hutton Institute, Wageningen University)
Preliminary – dependent on WP2-4 Ideas at this stage
Workpages 5 & 6 (James Hutton Institute, Wageningen University)
Aim WP5: quality check on the narratives behind policy WP6: quality check on the potential of innovations
Using framework developed in WP2-4: for real with stakeholders
WP5
behind directives
among narratives
narratives WP6
potential
potential
behind innovations? Nexus expressed?
narratives?
are inconsistencies in these narratives.
such narratives persist (avoid information deficit approach)
we are seeking to influence in our areas in the DoW
at innovation. Who are in these teams.
currently do (policy as designed and policy as enacted or current) via interviews of key participants.
Work Package 7 Nexus Knowledge Hub
WP3
NEXUS US Information
NEXUS US Dialog
ue Space
WP WP4
Defin finin ing the Quantitati ntitative ve Story ry-Tell Tellin ing
WP2
EU admini nist strat ration
WP1
interac eractions tions during ng the proje ject ct permanent manent platfo tform rm of
interac eraction tion
WP WP7
NEXUS Knowledg edge Hub Hub Quality check on
assessm essment of innovati ations
WP6
Quality check on
robustness ess of narrative ves
WP5
CASE STUDIES DIES
Knowledge Exchange
mediated modes of knowledge production
Post-Normal Science
Funtowicz & Ravetz 1993
Citizen engagement
– On-line forum – Helpdesk for enquires – Social media accounts (twitter & facebook)
A visual representation of the components of the MAGIC knowledge exchange, dissemination and exploitation plan
Citizen Engagement
Plurality of interfaces
* The Nexus Times * Videos, Material, FAQs * Social media * Discussion forums * Nexus hotline * Publications * Conferences * Routledge Book series * Text book on Nexus * Educational games * MOOCs * Syllabi + materials * Summer schools * Specific Training * Continuing Professional Development course * Ad-hoc tool-kits Decision support for a better informed societal deliberation A permanent contact point with the society
Tasks
(UAB, JRC, UiB)
Defining a Strategy for Dissemination, Communication, and Exploitation Identification of (i) target recipients, (ii) the communication strategy (frequency of communication, newsletter, science policy seminars, public seminars), (iii) language (teaching material, professional training, scientific report)
Ideas & suggestions?
(UAB, UNINA and all)
Online platform Within or linked to the project website Related to Dialogued Space WP2 Dedicated PhD student at JRC
7.2 Website (M 3) 7.5 Educational Nexus Game (M 42) 7.8 Leaflet (M 3)
(UAB, UNINA and all)
Ideas & suggestions? How can we make this truly interactive?
Twitter and facebook Hashtags? #MAGICNEXUS #NEXUS
https://www.facebook.com/MagicNexusEu https://twitter.com/MAGIC_NEXUS
@MAGIC_NEXUS
(UAB and all)
Conferences & Publications Obligation to publish in Open Access (manuscripts, data and bibliographic metadata) Book in the series Routledge Explorations in Sustainability and Governance
Other dissemination (UAB and all)
Teaching and training material on Nexus Assessment Training and Continuing Professional Development course MOOC in Coursera
5 Final conference (UAB and all)
Person-months UAB 38.00 HUTTON 12.00 WU 14.00 UT 15.00 UiB 3.00 JRC 10.00 UNINA 9.00 CA 15.00 ITC 4.00 120.00
Important for publications!!
Obligation to publish in Open Access (Publications, Data and Bibliographic metadata). Article 29 of the GA:
1 – upload final manuscript accepted for publication (pre-printed version?) in a repository for scientific publications (Knowledge Hub, Research Gate and Academia, …) 2 – ensure open access to the deposited publication — via the repository — at the latest: (i)
publisher, or (ii) within 6 months of publication (12 months for the social sciences and humanities) in any other case.
(a) deposit in a research data repository and take measures to make it possible for third parties to access, mine, exploit, reproduce and disseminate — free of charge for any user — the following: (i) the data, including associated metadata, needed to validate the results presented in scientific publications as soon as possible; (ii) other data, including associated metadata, as specified and within the deadlines laid down in the 'data management plan' (see Annex 1); (b) provide information — via the repository — about tools and instruments at the disposal of the beneficiaries and necessary for validating the results (and — where possible — provide the tools and instruments themselves).
Important for publications!!
EU GuidelinesGuidelines on Open Access to Scientific Publications and Research Data in Horizon 2020 http://ec.europa.eu/research/participants/data/ref/h2020/gra nts_manual/hi/oa_pilot/h2020-hi-oa-pilot-guide_en.pdf Related cost are eligible and go under "other direct costs"
Important for publications!!
Obligation to acknowledge EU funding and put disclaimer in any form of dissemination
Article 29.4 and 29.5 of the GA. Unless the Agency requests or agrees otherwise or unless it is impossible, any dissemination of results (in any form, including electronic) must: (a) display the EU emblem and (b) include the following text: “This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No 689669”. Any dissemination of results must indicate that it reflects only the author's view and that the Agency is not responsible for any use that may be made of the information it contains.
Obligation to inform other partners about the intention to publish/present results
Article 29.1 of the GA A beneficiary that intends to disseminate its results must give advance notice to the other beneficiaries of — unless agreed otherwise — at least 45 days, together with sufficient information on the results it will disseminate. Any other beneficiary may object within — unless agreed otherwise — 30 days
the results or background would be significantly harmed. In such cases, the dissemination may not take place unless appropriate steps are taken to safeguard these legitimate interests.
Article 8.3 Dissemination of the CA
Prior notice of any planned publication shall be given to the other Parties at least 45 calendar days before the publication. Any objection to the planned publication shall be made in accordance with the Grant Agreement in writing to the Coordinator and to the Party or Parties proposing the dissemination within 30 calendar days after receipt of the
publication is permitted
General communication guidelines
Horizon 2020 Guide "Communicating EU research and innovation guidance for project participants: http://ec.europa.eu/research/participants/data/ref/h2020/other/gm/h2020-guide- comm_en.pdf See also Article 38 of the GA.
Silvio’s corner – Post-Normal Twitting The sobering wisdom of Vaclav Smil Skeptical Energetics – Charlie Hall Climatic Monitoring – by C.A. Water level logger – by ? Andrea’s corner – evidence based or policy based?
THESE SE ARE JUST ST IDEAS AS . . . To To be be dis iscusse ussed
Fracking observer – by Cristina Madrid (Yale)
We We need need a a “The Nexus us Tim ime Tas ask Force rce”!