Interagency Working Group on Medical Imaging
National Science and Technology Council
Renée Cruea, MPA
Executive Director Academy of Radiology Research
Interagency Working Group on Medical Imaging National Science and - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
Interagency Working Group on Medical Imaging National Science and Technology Council Rene Cruea, MPA Executive Director Academy of Radiology Research Thank you The Academy of Radiology Research is an alliance of 27 professional imaging
Renée Cruea, MPA
Executive Director Academy of Radiology Research
The Academy of Radiology Research is an alliance of 27 professional imaging societies and 50 academic research departments, which together, represent the
scientific community advocating for more
sustainable medical research budgets. The Academy serves as the umbrella organization to the Coalition for Imaging and Bioengineering Research (CIBR). CIBR was established in order to foster collaboration among other important stakeholders in the imaging research community: imaging
equipment manufacturers, and patient advocates.
Organizational mission:
urging policymakers to invest more in federally funded R&D
imaging science as a surrogate for federally funded R&D
national re-commitment to high-impact R&D can fuel the US innovation economy in the same way that made Apple the largest company in the world
§ Science to Meet a National Need § Demand for Imaging Science § Teeing Up Subsequent Speakers
§ Science to Meet a National Need § Demand for Imaging Science § Teeing Up Subsequent Speakers
Medical Imaging Research Initiative - The Committee believes there is potential in the near future to accelerate revolutionary new imaging technology for medical professionals and researchers to combat disease and support high-skilled manufacturing jobs in the United States. Such advances will require inter-agency coordination of Federal medical imaging research and development initiatives to accelerate the transfer of new technologies into commercial products manufactured in the United States and strengthen innovative research programs. Since many Federal agencies have existing and complementary roles on medical imaging research, there is a strong need for a Federal strategy that will coordinate and accel-erate such research. The Committee directs OSTP, in cooperation with the National Institutes of Health as the lead agency, to establish, through the National Science and Technology Council's Committee on Science, a Medical Imaging Subcommittee [MIS] to coordinate Federal investments in imaging
research and development, including: basic STEM science and technology creation, medical and translational research, evidence generation, clinical implementation, workforce and training support, and export-oriented manufacturing incentives.
“This memorandum outlines the Administration's multi-agency science and technology priorities for formulating FY 2016 Budget submissions to the Office of Management and Budget (OMB). The priorities covered in this memo require investments in R&D; support for activities, such as science, technology, engineering, and mathematics (STEM) education, technology transfer, R&D facilities, and scientific data collection and management, that enable a robust science and technology enterprise; and cooperation among multiple Federal agencies.
“Innovation in life sciences, biology, and neuroscience: Agencies should give priority to programs that support fundamental biological discovery research that could generate unexpected, high-impact scientific and technological advances in health, energy, and food security, particularly in platform technologies.”
“Within research portfolios, Federal agencies are encouraged to identify and pursue clearly defined "Grand Challenges” - ambitious goals that require advances in science, technology and innovation to achieve and to support high- risk, high-return research”
“Agencies should consider, where appropriate and authorized, supplementing traditional R&D "push" mechanisms (e.g., grants and contracts) with "pull" mechanisms - results-based market incentives designed to overcome market failures, engage a wide range of solvers, and catalyze innovation, such as incentive prizes and advanced market commitments.”
“Great promise for developing such technologies lies at the intersections of nanoscience, imaging, biological engineering, informatics, and other rapidly emerging fields of science and engineering.”
§ Science to Meet a National Need § Demand for Imaging Science § Teeing Up Subsequent Speakers
!$1,338!! !$1,652!! !$1,791!! !$1,889!! !$2,020!! !$2,148!! !$2,848!! !$3,052!! !$3,154!! !$3,257!! !$3,319!! !$3,772!! !$3,506!! !$3,634!! !$520!! !$696!!
6.5%% 7.1%% 6.6%% 6.7%% 7.1%% 7.5%% 9.8%% 10.3%% 10.3%% 10.4%% 10.7%% 12.2%% 12.0%% 12.1%%
$0! $500! $1,000! $1,500! $2,000! $2,500! $3,000! $3,500! $4,000! $4,500! 2001! 2002! 2003! 2004! 2005! 2006! 2007! 2008! 2009! 2010! 2011! 2012! 2013! 2014!
"Positron-Emission Tomography" ultrasound tomography radiology MRI "magnetic resonance" "molecular imaging" "optical imaging" "imaging biomarkers" "MR elastography" "quantitative imaging" "image analysis" "image informatics" "image-guided"
!$#!!!! !$100!! !$200!! !$300!! !$400!! !$500!! !$600!! !$700!! 2005! 2006! 2007! 2008! 2009! 2010! 2011! 2012! 2013! 2014! Millions' NCI! NHLBI! NIMH! NINDS! NIBIB! NIA! NIDDK! NICHD! NIDA! NEI! NIAMS!
0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% 30% % dollars imaging FY08 % dollars imaging CG % dollars imaging FY11
NIA NIAMS NEI NIDCD NIMH NHLBI NICHD NCI NIDDK NIDA
Percent of an IC’s Portfolio Imaging
$63,854,335 $80,093,162 $88,410,896 $78,449,154 $101,160,327 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012
"Positron-Emission Tomography" "computed tomography" "computerized tomography" radiology "MRI" "magnetic resonance" "molecular imaging" "optical imaging" "imaging biomarkers" "MR elastography" "quantitative imaging" "image informatics" "image-guided"
"Positron-Emission Tomography" "computed tomography" "computerized tomography" radiology "MRI" "magnetic resonance" "molecular imaging" "optical imaging" "imaging biomarkers" "MR elastography" "quantitative imaging" "image informatics" "image-guided"
$1,049,115( $181,882( $715,173( $1,792,645( $1,763,519( $2,383,308( $4,698,469(
2008( 2009( 2010( 2011( 2012( 2013( 2014(
453$ 689$ 721$ 459$ 420$ 460$ 457$ 2008$ 2009$ 2010$ 2011$ 2012$ 2013$ 2014$
"Positron-Emission Tomography" "computed tomography" "computerized tomography" radiology "MRI" "magnetic resonance" "molecular imaging" "optical imaging" "imaging biomarkers" "MR elastography" "quantitative imaging" "image informatics" "image-guided"
"Positron-Emission Tomography" "computed tomography" "computerized tomography" radiology "MRI" "magnetic resonance" "molecular imaging" "optical imaging" "imaging biomarkers" "MR elastography" "quantitative imaging" "image informatics" "image-guided"
19# 1# 44# 85# 89# 171#
2009# 2010# 2011# 2012# 2013# 2014#
§ Science to Meet a National Need § Demand for Imaging Science § Teeing Up Subsequent Speakers
NIBIB NCI NSF DOD/VA NASA NIST FDA CMS
Academy of Radiology Research Renée L. Cruea Executive Director rcruea@acadrad.org
Diagnostic Burr Holes Advanced Medical Imaging Bleeding?
Exploratory Surgery Pancreatic Cancer?
Advances in medical imaging have had an unparalleled impact on health care. The medical imaging research initiative proposes an intensified strategic focus
innovative science that addresses critical national needs. Research in the field of medical imaging is:
engineering to critical medical needs The advances achieved by use-inspired medical imaging research are historically:
Inventions, embodied in patents, are a major driver of long-term regional economic performance, especially if the patents are of higher quality. In recent decades, patenting is associated with higher productivity growth, lower unemployment rates, and the creation of more publicly-traded companies.
Average 5.9 citations per patent
NIBIB NIGMS NIAID NCI NHGRI NHLBI NIDDK NINDS NIA NICHD NIMH NIDCR NIDCD NEI NIDA NIAAA NIEHS NIAMS NIMHD NINR NCCAM DARPA NSF DOE
1 4 16 64 5 10 15
NIH Nobelists
NCCAM Complementary and Alternative Med NCI Cancer Institute NEI Eye Institute NHGRI Human Genome Research Institute NHLBI Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute NIA Institute on Aging NIAAA Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism NIAID Allergy and Infectious Diseases NIAMS Arthritis, Musculoskeletal, and Skin Dis NIBIB Biomedical Imaging and Bioengineering NICHD Child Health and Human Development NIDA Drug Abuse NIDCD Deafness and Communication Disorders NIDCR Dental and Craniofacial Research NIDDK Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Dis NIEHS Environmental Health Sciences NIGMS General Medical Sciences NIMH Mental Health NIMHD Minority Health and Health Disparities NINDS Neurological Disorders and Stroke NINR Nursing Research
Average 4.2 patents per $100M
Donald E. Stokes 1927-1997
Pasteur Quadrant
Bohr Quadrant Pure Basic Research Use-Inspired Research Edison Quadrant Applied Research
NIBIB NIGMS NIAID NCI NHGRI NHLBI NIDDK NINDS NIA NICHD NIMH NIDCR NIDCD NEI NIDA NIAAA NIEHS NIAMS NIMHD NINR NCCAM DARPA NSF DOE
1 4 16 64 5 10 15
NIH Nobelists
Cooley-Tukey Butterfly
0.0
5.0 10.0 15.0 5 10 15
Patents per $100 M of R&D Funding Mean Citations per Patent
NIH DOE NSF DOC/NIST
characterization and classification
imaging acquisition protocols, technology standards, data analysis, display methods, and reporting structures.
anatomically and physiologically relevant parameters, such as treatment response and outcome.
data sets
55+ groundwork projects
Europe, Japan, and Brazil
incorporated into industry and federally- funded clinical trials
to emphasize quantitative ability
variability, increased accuracy, and substantial capability improvements
quantitative imaging biomarker measurands => smaller sample sizes
efficiently scale-up and accelerate the scope and impact of the QIBA process to realize the great promise of quantitative imaging in health care
appropriate
CAD in Mammography "Ambient Medical Image Analytics" in Medical Imaging Workflow
Aneurysm "sniffer" system B Erickson, MD Mayo Clinic
Avascular necrosis of the femoral head
ca 1900 ca 1969
General Electric Co. Global Research chief engineer, Trifon Laskaris, stands next to a 3-tesla Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) scanner, used for scanning heads only, which he is process of building, Monday May 6, 2013, at GE Global Research in Niskayuna, N.Y. Laskaris was recently awarded his 200th U.S. patent. The 3-T scanner would mark 201 patents, and he has another 25
2015: First Human Images from Low-cost Compact 3T System
10 20 30 40 50 60
Open MRI Standard 3T MRI High Performance 3T Low Cost Compact 3T Connectome 3T
MRI System Performance: Slew rate * Gmax
Mitchell Schnall MD, PhD Chair ACR Research Commission
Eugene Pendergrass Professor of Radiology The Perelman School of Medicine at the University of Pennsylvania
11/2/15 ¡ 2 ¡
– Over 500 clinical trials – 2 million images processed annually
– 16,000 square feet of office space – 120 researcher professionals – ACR Imaging Core Laboratories – Can accommodate up to 50 readers simultaneously – Health Policy Institute – Socio-Economic Research – 8 Reston Employees
Neiman ¡ Health ¡Policy ¡ Ins2tute ¡ IROC ¡ NRG ¡
Opera2ons ¡ Head ¡Injury ¡ Ins2tute ¡ Cardiovascular ¡ Commi=ee ¡
ACR ¡RESEARCH ¡COMMISSION ¡
Health ¡Services ¡ Research ¡
Neuro ¡ Commi=ee ¡
ECOG-‑ACRIN ¡
ACR ¡Peds ¡ Commission ¡
ACR ¡Research ¡and ¡Innova2on ¡ ¡
RTOG ¡ Founda2on ¡
Industry ¡
ACRIN ¡ ¡ Industry ¡
Pediatric ¡ Commi=ee ¡ ECOG-‑ACRIN ¡ Opera2ons ¡ Industry ¡ ¡ Data ¡ Management ¡
Radia2on ¡ Oncology ¡
NRG ¡Data ¡
Management ¡
and ¡ ¡
Sta2s2cs ¡
Imaging
Science Community
Imaging Standards Organizations
Imaging
Industry
Clinical Providers Multicenter translational and clinical imaging research to translate innovation to practice Training a generation of imaging clinical trialists Contribution of methods and standards for imaging clinical trials
Government
§ Accrued over 75,000 patients to imaging related clinical trials § Developed a network of over 200 sites to participate in multicenter imaging trials § Deployed a clinical trials image management IT infrastructure (TRIAD) across 7000 sites.
§ Integrated with Medidata RAVE
§ Integrated program with the NCI Quantitative Imaging Network program (QIN) § Organized a distribution network for experimental radiopharmaceuticals.
Arm Person Years (py) Lung cancer deaths Lung cancer mortality per 100,000 py Reduction in lung cancer mortality (%)
CT 144,097.6 354 245 20.3 CXR 143,363.5 442 308
ER discharge Rate CT: 49.6%; Control: 22.7% Length of Stay CT:18 hours; Control:24.6 hours Dx of CAD CT:9%; Control:3.5%
No difference in rate of MI or Death
§ Activates in early 2016. § Created by and funded by the Alzheimer’s Association § Additional funding by Industry
11
A Phase II Study of 3′-Deoxy-3′-18F- Fluorothymidine PET in the Assessment of Early Response of Breast Cancer to Neoadjuvant Chemotherapy: Results from ACRIN 6688
Lale Kostakoglu1, Fenghai Duan2, Michael O. Idowu3, Paul R. Jolles3, Harry D. Bear3,4, Mark Muzi5, Jean Cormack2, John P. Muzi5, Daniel A. Pryma6, Jennifer M. Specht5, Linda Hovanessian-Larsen7, John Miliziano8, Sharon Mallett9, Anthony F. Shields10 and David A. Mankoff6 on behalf of the ACRIN 668 Investigative Team behalf of the ACRIN 668 Investigative Team
Protocol development Site qualification Site management QA review Analysis Image management Protocol development Analysis QA review Site qualification Site management Image management
Scanner PACS
Localizer
Image DICOM Dose Structured Report Dose Sheet DICOM
1. De-identification
2. Normalization 3. Authentication 4. Transmission
TRIAD Site Server TRIAD Central Services
Web Services
Dose Registry
Imaging Facility ACR
Post Processing NRDR Portal Facility and Benchmark Reports
1000 2000 3000 4000 5000 6000 7000 8000 4 8 12 16 19
Accreditation Clinical Trials Registries 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 Q3
the public and commercial sectors, academic and private practices, urban and rural settings, and civilian and military institutions.
widespread movement of imaging data.
Rave Pt Reports
Records Claims data Registries Digital Pathology
Images
Laboratory Data
Data Warehouse
High Throughput Genomics
Data exploration interface
17
James H Thrall MD
Chairman Emeritus, Department of Radiology Massachusetts General Hospital Distinguished Juan M Taveras Professor of Radiology Harvard Medical School International Society for Strategic Studies in Radiology (IS3R)
Precision Medicine
Radiogenomics
Molecularly targeted imaging Deep Learning– Big data, data mining
Data into knowledge Radiomics– quantitative tissue signatures
(phenotypes)
“I want the country that eliminated polio and mapped the human genome to lead a new era of medicine — one that delivers the right treatment at the right time. …Tonight, I'm launching a new Precision Medicine Initiative to bring us closer to curing diseases like cancer and diabetes — and to give all of us access to the personalized information we need to keep ourselves and our families healthier.” President Barack Obama, State-of-the-Union speech, Jan 20, 2015 $215 million in proposed budget specifically for precision medicine initiatives
“The tailoring of medical treatment to the individual
characteristics of each patient”
“Classification of patients into subpopulations that differ
in their susceptibility to a particular disease, in the biology and/or prognosis of those diseases, or in response to a specific treatment”
Subpopulations defined by genotype and phenotype
National Research Council of the National Academies, White Paper, 2011
The study of the linkage between genotype and imaging phenotype
When Genotype is known:
What are the image findings associated with gene expression? (I.e. imaging phenotype)
When Imaging Phenotype is known (I.e. image findings):
What is the genotype?
Patient with NF1
Whole body MRI with image segmentation
Genotype is known– what are the manifestations of gene expression? What is the imaging the phenotype?
Texture energy maps from a cecal tumor Selected ROI
S Do, C Cruz Romero, MGH
signature
lowest average texture energies
highest average texture energies
S Do, C Cruz Romero, MGH
Biomarkers and Phenotypes
in is
(ADC DC—Apparent D Diffusio ion Coefficient)
Nakamura K, Imafuku N, Nishida T, et al. Gynecol Oncol 2012;124:335–339.
111 patients with preoperative DWI
CA--125 (Cancer Antigen 125) ADCmin
ECOG—ACRIN
Cancer Research Group
Gallam ini et al. JCO, 2 0 0 7
International Prognostic Score
Gallam ini et al. JCO, 2 0 0 7
18F-FDG PET/CT
Glycolysis
18F-FDHT PET/CT
Androgen Receptor
Revealing Heterogeneous Biology
CT
Hricak H.: Oncologic Imaging: A Guiding Hand
Zr-89 J591 PSMA mAb*
18F-FDG PET/CT
Glycolysis CT
*Pandit-Taskar, Eur J Nucl Med Mol Imaging: 2014
Revealing Heterogeneous Biology
A TYPE OF MACHINE LEARNING USING AI AND NEURAL NETWORKS
WITH MINIMAL HUMAN INPUT (UNSUPERVISED)
REQUIRES LARGE DATA SOURCES FOR SYSTEM TRAINING
K Dreyer, MGH
Untrained Neural Network DOG CAT FISH HUMAN Trained Neural Network
K Dreyer, MGH
Extraction of large numbers (hundreds)
Quantitative imaging phenotypes
Radiomic image analysis can be applied
Tissue heterogeneity (proteins, cells,
microenvironment) limits usefulness of biopsy based molecular assays
Segmentation of tumor Analysis– size, shape, intensity, texture Analysis
From www.radiomics.org
Radiomics Heat Map
440 quantitative features
Exploit US leadership in medical
Precision Medicine and patient phenotype:
Validation of imaging biomarkers Correlation of image data with other information sources to
better classify patients into more precise subpopulations (sub phenotypes)
Disease biology:
Imaging phenotypes provide clues to disease biology– gene
expression
○ Differences in presence, location, extent and behavior of
diseases
○ Differences in response to treatment
Molecularly targeted imaging
○ Probe development ○ Probe application
Cancer heterogeneity
Imaging and Treatment:
New imaging criteria for selection of therapy New criteria for monitoring response to therapy Imaging informed adaptive therapy New criteria for establishing prognosis
Imaging and Clinical trials:
Use of imaging inclusion criteria in patient
selection for clinical trials
Use of imaging biomarkers as surrogate
endpoints in clinical trials
Exploit US lead in computing capabilities
Build data bases available for data mining Support research in multi- information source
Deep Learning
○ Mobilize the Deep Learning toolkit ○ Establish reference data sets to compare methods
Criteria Standards
Establish registries:
○ Imaging biomarkers ○ Phenotyping systems-- radiomics ○ Radiogenomic linkages