ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
response to the opioid crisis Dissemination & Implementation - - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
Indianas policy & programmatic response to the opioid crisis Dissemination & Implementation 2017 ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH www.indianactsi.org Portfolio of Indiana opioid studies 1. Indiana naloxone access
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
attention to external factors in implementation work (Clinton-McHarg et al. 2016; Lewis et al., 2015)
good start, but rooted in theory (e.g., Damschroder et al. 2009, Aarons, et al. 2011)
conducted to develop external constructs based on empirical
Watson, DP, Adams, EL, Shue, S, Coates, H, McGuire, A, Chesher, J, Jackson, J, & Omenka, Isaac. (revise & resubmit). The external implementation context: an integrative systematic literature review. BMC Health Services Research.
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
Table 2. Comparison of constructs evidenced through literature review with external factor constructs in existing frameworks Consolidate Framework for Implementation Research (CFIR) Exploration, Preparation, Implementation, Sustainment (EPIS)* Multi-level framework (MLF) predicting implementation outcomes Professional influences
networks
advocacy Political or social climate Social climate
Local infrastructure
Policy & legal climate External policies and incentives
Relational climate Cosmopolitanism Interorganizational networks
Patient needs and resources Client advocacy
climate
Economic climate No directly comparable construct Peer pressure Intervention developers; Leadership Physical environment “--“ = No directly comparable construct *Only the active implementation phase of the EPIS framework is considered here since this was the focus
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
Aarons GA, Hurlburt M, Horwitz SM. Advancing a conceptual model of evidence-based practice implementation in public service sectors. Adm Policy Ment Health Ment Health Serv Res. 2011;38:4–23. Clinton-McHarg T, Yoong SL, Tzelepis F, Regan T, Fielding A, Skelton E, et al. Psychometric properties of implementation measures for public health and community settings and mapping of constructs against the Consolidated Framework for Implementation Research: a systematic review. Implement Sci. 2016;11:148. Damschroder LJ, Aron DC, Keith RE, Kirsh SR, Alexander JA, Lowery JC. Fostering implementation of health services research findings into practice: a consolidated framework for advancing implementation
Lewis CC, Stanick CF, Martinez RG, Weiner BJ, Kim M, Barwick M, et al. The Society for Implementation Research Collaboration Instrument Review Project: a methodology to promote rigorous evaluation. Implement Sci. 2015;10:2.
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
= 2.4 times more likely to call police (p < .001)
who did not call 911 worried about police
show similar trends, with even greater percentage (43%) worried about police.
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
http://www.in.gov/dol/2907.htm
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
10th Annual Implementation and Dissemination Conference December 5, 2017 Brad Ray, PhD, Johanne Eliacin, PhD, HSPP, Dennis P. Watson, PhD, Lisa Robison, MPH, & Phil Huynh, MPH
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
– Porter, Stark, and LaPorte Counties
– Scott County
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
Porter Starke Services LifeSpring Health Systems
Program Characteristics
with barriers to MAT
HIV/Hep C, or barriers accessing MAT
Location Characteristics
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
Porter Starke Services LifeSpring Health Systems
Client Characteristics
Age (average) 35.0 Female 51% Male 49% Unemployed 64% Probation/Parole 17% Illegal Drug Use 82% Opioid Use 71% IV Drug Use 55% Age (average) 36.3 Female 62% Male 38% Unemployed 49% Probation/Parole 34% Illegal Drug Use 50% Opioid Use 31% IV Drug Use 19%
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
External Factors
Funding & Economic Target Population Policy & Legal Local Infrastructure Professional Influences Political Support Social Climate Relational Climate
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
Porter Starke Services LifeSpring Health Systems
Located close to Chicago metropolitan area, so slightly more accepting of harm reduction Long history in the community; existing facility, local reputation and community networks Part of large, locally integrated health program, which facilitates referrals and name recognition Distance for rural clients increased fuel costs and time Conservative community with resistance from churches and community leaders = stigma Difficulties forming relationships with existing health providers Difficulty recruiting HIV-impacted population program meant to serve = internalized stigma Clients lack transportation, even though within short distance of clinic
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
– 40 questions in 8 domains 1. Environmental 2. Funding 3. Partners
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
Porter Starke Services LifeSpring Health Systems
Luke, D. A. (2014). The Program Sustainability Assessment Tool: a new instrument for public health programs. Preventing chronic disease, 11.
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
Porter Starke Services LifeSpring Health Systems Strong champions for MAT are outside of the program Community stigma against MAT Community stigma against MAT Lack of community trust
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
Porter Starke Services LifeSpring Health Systems
Luke, D. A. (2014). The Program Sustainability Assessment Tool: a new instrument for public health programs. Preventing chronic disease, 11.
MAT is not seen as priority in marking and they cannot circumvent Discontinue comprehensive services without additional funding
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
Porter Starke Services LifeSpring Health Systems High need pop. w/ limited resources Loosing traditional self-pay clients to new MAT-PDOA clients Private funders prefer to give to prevention services High need pop. w/ limited resources Grant funding is only source of funding for comprehensive services Uncertainty regarding ACA
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
Porter Starke Services LifeSpring Health Systems
Stigma and a need for stronger community partners
Luke, D. A. (2014). The Program Sustainability Assessment Tool: a new instrument for public health programs. Preventing chronic disease, 11.
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
Porter Starke Services LifeSpring Health Systems
Stigma and a need for stronger community partners
Caution around promoting MAT Physician stigma regarding MAT Small community with strong ties means new partnerships are hard to develop Religious values are anti-MAT
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
implementation outcomes for the IMAP program
different external factors: social, political, relational
community values and interlinked small town networks
implementation outcomes
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org ED-Based Team Substance Abuse Treatment PRC Alert/Referral System Transportation ED- Based
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
someone from that team would come to the emergency department to see overdose patients…Didn't work out very well because often by the time the person extricated themselves from whatever they were doing and got here…Sometimes the patient was gone, or they were ready to be gone
"what…who are you and what are you doing?”
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org ED-Based Team Substance Abuse Treatment Walk- in Clinic Special MAT Prescriber Buy- in/Communication with Providers Insurance/Fu nding
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
giving them appointments. They're not gonna keep an appointment, that's not how they're living their
just going wasted. But if we can say "hey 3 days out of the week, you can just walk in at 10 am"…they can do that. That's how they
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
ACCELERATING CLINICAL AND TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH
www.indianactsi.org
1- Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). Vital signs: overdoses of prescription opioid pain relievers---United States, 1999--2008. MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep. 2011;60:1487–92. 2- D’Onofrio, G., O’Connor, P. G., Pantalon, M. V., Chawarski, M. C., Busch, S. H., Owens,
buprenorphine/naloxone treatment for opioid dependence: a randomized clinical
3- Bond, G. R., Williams, J., Evans, L., Salyers, M., Kim, H. W., Sharpe, H., & Leff, H. S. (2000). Psychiatric rehabilitation fidelity toolkit. Cambridge, MA: Human Services Research Institute.